Silicone Butt Plugs
Shop silicone butt plugs in smooth, textured and contoured designs. Explore different shapes, base styles and sizes, including powered options and plug sets. Compare the listed material details, dimensions and lubricant compatibility for the particular model you choose.
Find more choices in our full anal toys collection, or explore anal training kits. Shop HimAndHerToys with discreet packaging. Review each product’s intended use, measurements and compatibility details before ordering.
Evolved Novelties
Evolved Novelties Advanced Metal Anal Plug — Black Chrome
Regular price $71.98Unit priceVery low stock (4 units)Doc Johnson
GoodHead Party Pack — 5‑Piece Oral & Anal Kit
Regular price $37.46Unit priceVery low stock (4 units)Cloud 9 Novelties
Cloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Large
Regular price $17.90Unit priceLow stock (13 units)Perfect Fit
Perfect Fit Tunnel Plug — Medium, Clear
Regular price $35.95Unit priceLow stock (15 units)XR Brands
XR Brands Aria Small Silicone Vibrating Anal Plug, Purple
Regular price $37.88Unit priceLow stock (9 units)CalExotics
CalExotics Medium Inflatable Silicone Plug with Suction Cup (4.25 x 1.25 in)
Regular price $52.99Unit priceLow stock (14 units)XR Brands
XR Brands Dark Invader Metal and Silicone Anal Plug — Medium
Sale price $35.05 Regular price $35.06Unit priceVery low stock (4 units)Satisfyer
Satisfyer Lolli Plug 1 Anal Plug — Dark Teal
Regular price $49.95Unit priceVery low stock (4 units)Oxballs
Oxballs Morph Hole 1 — Small Toy-Stuffing Anal Plug, Black Ice
Regular price $76.00Unit priceVery low stock (5 units)Nu Sensuelle
Nu Sensuelle Mini Anal Plug — Rechargeable, Black
Regular price $49.99Unit priceVery low stock (1 unit)Hott Products
Hott Products Strawberry Mini Vibe Ring — Liquid Silicone, 10 Speeds
Regular price $21.00Unit priceVery low stock (1 unit)Hott Products
Hott Products Peach Fuzz Mini Peach-Shaped Vibrator — Liquid Silicone
Regular price $28.00Unit priceVery low stock (4 units)Hott Products
Hott Products Edgy Veggies Corn Holer Mini Vibe Ring — Liquid Silicone, Pocket-Size
Regular price $23.99Unit priceVery low stock (3 units)Tom of Finland
Tom of Finland XL Silicone Anal Plug — 5.5 in, Black
Regular price $67.95Unit priceVery low stock (1 unit)Thunderplugs
Thunderplugs Silicone Swelling & Thrusting Anal Plug with Remote — Black
Regular price $165.95Unit priceVery low stock (1 unit)Thump It
Thump It Kinetic Thumping 7X Prostate Anal Plug — Black
Regular price $160.95Unit priceVery low stock (1 unit)