Discreet Packaging on Every Order

Secure Checkout • Adults 18+

Silicone Butt Plugs

Shop silicone butt plugs in smooth, textured and contoured designs. Explore different shapes, base styles and sizes, including powered options and plug sets. Compare the listed material details, dimensions and lubricant compatibility for the particular model you choose.

Find more choices in our full anal toys collection, or explore anal training kits. Shop HimAndHerToys with discreet packaging. Review each product’s intended use, measurements and compatibility details before ordering.

View as

  • 20% off

    Blush

    Blush Vibra Slim Plug — Medium Black Silicone Anal Plug

    Sale price $19.99 Regular price $24.99
    Very low stock (2 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Blush Anal Adventures Prostate Stimulator, Black

    Sale price $9.59 Regular price $11.99
    In stock (45 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Prostate Massager, Black

    Sale price $32.79 Regular price $40.99
    Low stock (19 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibrating Prostate Massager, Black

    Sale price $30.39 Regular price $37.99
    In stock (23 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Blush Platinum Silicone Prostate Massager — Black, 3.5" Insertable

    Sale price $27.99 Regular price $34.99
    Very low stock (5 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibrating Prostate Massager — Black

    Sale price $30.39 Regular price $37.99
    Low stock (16 units)
    View details
  • CalExotics

    CalExotics XL Inflatable Silicone Anal Plug

    Regular price $60.99
    Very low stock (3 units)
    View details
  • VeDO

    VeDO Bump Plus Rechargeable Remote Anal Vibe — Just Black

    Regular price $63.99
    In stock (39 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Anal Adventures - Platinum - Cock Ring Plug - Black

    Sale price $18.39 Regular price $22.99
    Low stock (15 units)
    View details
  • XR Brands

    Hive Ass Tunnel Silicone Ribbed Hollow Anal Plug - Medium

    Regular price $23.30
    Very low stock (7 units)
    View details
  • Pipedream

    Fantasy for Her - Her Little Gems Trainer Set

    Regular price $49.99
    Low stock (12 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Temptasia - Bling Plug Small - Purple

    Sale price $11.19 Regular price $13.99
    Very low stock (6 units)
    View details
  • Icon Brands

    The 9's Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug - Pink

    Regular price $14.95
    In stock (29 units)
    View details
  • Cloud 9 Novelties

    Cloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Small

    Regular price $13.06
    Low stock (17 units)
    View details
  • 20% off

    Blush

    Luxe - Wearable Vibra Slim Plug - Small - Black

    Sale price $20.79 Regular price $25.99
    Very low stock (1 unit)
    View details
  • Cloud 9 Novelties

    Cloud 9 Novelties Gems Silicone Anal Plug - Includes Small, Med & Large Size

    Regular price $32.56
    In stock (24 units)
    View details
  • Cloud 9 Novelties

    Cloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Medium

    Regular price $15.42
    Low stock (20 units)
    View details
  • Evolved Novelties

    Mini Butt Plug - Black

    Regular price $41.98
    Low stock (14 units)
    View details