Butt Plugs
Shop butt plugs in different shapes, materials and sizes, from simple tapered designs to textured and powered styles. Compare the insertable dimensions, neck shape and base design in each listing. Browse individual plugs and sets to find the features you prefer.
Find more choices in our full anal toys collection, or explore anal training kits. Shop HimAndHerToys with discreet packaging. Review each product’s intended use, measurements and compatibility details before ordering.
Blush
Temptasia - Bling Plug - Small - Black
Sale price $11.19 Regular price $13.99Unit priceLow stock (17 units)nsnovelties
nsnovelties Firefly Mini Pleasure Plug — Blue
Regular price $11.20Unit priceIn stock (52 units)nsnovelties
nsnovelties Firefly Mini Pleasure Plug - Pink
Regular price $11.20Unit priceVery low stock (8 units)Blush
Blush B Yours Eclipse Pleaser — Small Anal Plug, Pink
Sale price $7.99 Regular price $9.99Unit priceIn stock (23 units)CalExotics
CalExotics First Time Crystal Beaded Duo — Purple, 2 Beaded Anal Probes
Regular price $26.99Unit priceLow stock (13 units)CalExotics
CalExotics First Time Booty Probe Duo — Pink (2-Pack Anal Probes)
Regular price $19.99Unit priceIn stock (36 units)Pretty Love
Pretty Love Special Anal Stimulation Plug — 12-Speed Silicone, Black
Regular price $21.60Unit priceIn stock (87 units)Viben
Viben Gemma Small Black Silicone Anal Plug with Pink Gem
Regular price $16.20Unit priceIn stock (144 units)Nasstoys
Nasstoys Atomic Inflatable Anal Plug - Black
Regular price $34.90Unit priceVery low stock (1 unit)nsnovelties
nsnovelties Rear Assets Medium Anal Plug — Silver with Yellow Gem
Regular price $22.20Unit priceIn stock (22 units)nsnovelties
nsnovelties Rear Assets Medium Anal Plug — Silver with Pink Gem
Regular price $22.20Unit priceLow stock (18 units)nsnovelties
nsnovelties Rear Assets Anal Plug — Small Chrome with Yellow Gem
Regular price $20.00Unit priceIn stock (37 units)nsnovelties
nsnovelties Rear Assets Small Aluminum Anal Plug — Silver with Pink Gem
Regular price $20.00Unit priceLow stock (11 units)VeDO
VeDO Hump Silicone Anal Plug — 4.25in Purple
Regular price $16.99Unit priceVery low stock (4 units)VeDO
VeDO Hump Silicone Anal Plug — Black, 4.25 in, Non-Vibrating
Regular price $16.99Unit priceVery low stock (3 units)Femme Funn
Femme Funn Bougie Plug — Anodized Aluminum Butt Plug, Rose Gold (3.5" x 1.3")
Regular price $110.00Unit priceLow stock (9 units)